Joseph Smith Seer Stones: Was Joseph Smith Really Uneducated When He Translated the Book of Mormon?

Fact Checked by Kevin Prince

Some may wonder why God used Joseph Smith, an uneducated man, to bring forth the Book of Mormon? And, did he use seer stones to translate the Book of Mormon? While Joseph did receive some basic education before translating the Book of Mormon, his friends, family, associates, and even critics all described him as relatively unlearned. His wife, Emma, for example, explained that at the time of the translation, he “could neither write nor dictate a coherent and well-worded letter.” Martin Harris similarly declared that Joseph was “a poor writer, and could not even draw up a note of hand as his education was so limited.” 

Samples of Joseph’s early writings, including their lack of punctuation and frequently misspelled words, help confirm these descriptions. For example, Joseph himself stated that he was “deprived of the bennifit of an education” and was “mearly instructtid in reading writing and the ground rules of Arithmatic.”

It’s also noteworthy that the destitute circumstances of the Smith family required long hours of “continuous labor” from all who were capable of work. With this in mind, one literary scholar has argued that Joseph simply wouldn’t have had the time “to read broadly, undertake research, construct various drafts, and work out the plot, characters, settings, various points of view, and multiple rhetorical styles that constitute the five-hundred-plus page narrative of the Book of Mormon.”

Even if he did have the time, he clearly lacked the educational opportunities and literary development that the great writers of his day all seem to have had.

Yet despite these limitations, Joseph Smith, unlike other notable 19th-century authors, produced a literary and scriptural masterpiece at the beginning, rather than the conclusion, of his development as a writer. Numerous studies have shown that the Book of Mormon is far more complex, sophisticated, and historically authentic than many people realize.

And yet, somehow, it was brought to the world by an unlearned 23-year-old farmer, who dictated its lengthy text in no more than 74 working days without notes or reference materials, and without any substantive revisions. Additionally, Joseph Smith translated the Book of Mormon using translation instruments and seer stones

Joseph Smith’s lack of education and experience strongly emphasize the miraculous and divine nature of the Book of Mormon’s translation. They also meaningfully fulfill Nephi’s prophecy that the Book of Mormon would be brought forth by a “man that is not learned.”

Fact checked by Mr. Kevin Prince, Source Expert

Kevin Prince is a religious scholar and the YouTube host of the Gospel Learning YouTube Channel. With over 41,000 subscribers and 4.5 million views, his channel has become a significant platform for exploring religious topics. Additionally, Mr. Prince is the creator of the Gospel Learning App, a reliable resource that provides trustworthy answers to religious questions, drawing from insights shared by some of the world’s best teachers.

ABOUT JOSEPH SMITH SEER STONES

Our objective at Joseph Smith Seer Stones is to provide a precise and impartial exploration of the history and doctrines of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. In a landscape filled with sanitized history, misinformation, and inaccuracies, our goal is to deliver genuine information and unbiased perspectives to those sincerely seeking the truth.